Memorandum Of Intent For IAFP And ICFP Merger Into FPA
Download a copy of the Memorandum Of Intent And Commitment below.
Advancing Knowledge in Financial Planning
IAR CE is only available if your organization contracts with Kitces.com for the credit.
Please contact your firm's group administrator to enable this feature.
If you do not know who your group administrator is you may contact [email protected]
Download a copy of the Memorandum Of Intent And Commitment below.
Download a copy of the Unifying And Professionalizing The Financial Planning Segments Of The Financial Services Industry (One Profession – One Designation) by Kemp Fain below.
Download a copy of the Financial Planning Association (FPA) Bylaws below.
Financial advisors have had to navigate many challenges in 2022, from an inflationary environment, the likes of which we have not experienced in decades, to weak stock and bond market performance. Here at Kitces.com, we have sought to provide advisors with the insights and education they need to help their clients (and their firms) navigate these uncertain conditions, from blog posts and podcasts on these trending topics to the continued expansion of our Kitces Courses and our popular monthly Office Hours and webinars.
Earlier this year, we introduced our own Investment Adviser Representative (IAR) CE programs that allow those in the growing number of states that have adopted the NASAA Model Rule to meet their 12 hours/year CE requirement. Combined with the continued availability of CE credit for CFP certification, CPA and EA licenses, and various Investment & Wealth Institute (IWI) and American College designations, Kitces Premier Members have a wide variety of opportunities to fulfill their CE requirements.
To keep pace with the current inflationary environment (which also comes with a new CFP Board fee for CE credits and rising staff costs), the Kitces Members Section will be implementing a concomitant $20/year increase in its annual membership fee for Premier Members in 2023, from $149/year to $169/year (the first increase in 3 years!). In addition, Kitces.com will be required to collect a new $36/year “IAR CE Reporting Fee” from advisers who choose to earn IAR CE with Kitces.com to cover the new mandatory reporting costs being imposed on CE providers reporting CE credits completed by IARs.
Notably, as part of the pricing change, we will be making significant investments into the back end of the Kitces platform on behalf of members as well, including hiring a new Senior Director of Platform and Product, who will lead our 2 full-time developers in a significant overhaul of the underlying architecture of the site, to make it faster and easier to navigate in the year(s) to come! We will also be hiring a new Director of Advisor Education, Instructional DesigNerd, and Director of Advisor research soon to support our efforts to provide the best educational content for Advicers. Advisors can also look forward to the release of our newest Kitces Course, “How To Review Insurance Documents To Ensure Clients Understand Their Risk And Address Gaps In Their Coverage” in early 2023, and can take a look at new investments in our AdvisorTech Directory, including the addition of AdvisorTech Satisfaction scores and Integration scores.
In 2023, Kitces Premier Members will also get to experience new formats for our monthly Office Hours sessions, which will include “Software Showcases” to help advisors select between tools in key AdvisorTech categories, as well as “Advisor Makeover” sessions, where industry consultants and I will give advisors real-time feedback on their websites, pricing, firm finances, compensation structures and more!
Ultimately, though, we are still just getting going with the ongoing growth of the Kitces platform as we continue to execute on providing Advicers with relevant content across our 4 strategic pillars: Navigation, Education, Research, and Development (and yes, our organizational strategy really does spell out N-E-R-D!). All in pursuit of our mission: Making Financial Advicers Better, And More Successful. I hope you’ll continue the journey along with us in 2023 and beyond!
For investment advisers looking to attract prospective clients, advertising the performance of their investment strategies would be a logical way to market their services (at least if they had strong historical returns!). But for many years, advisers looking for guidance from the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) regarding what kind of performance advertising was permissible had to rely on fairly general guidelines and SEC staff statements in the form of “no-action” letters. But now, as part of its recently overhauled Marketing Rule (which also clarifies the rules surrounding investment adviser testimonials and endorsements), the SEC has codified its previous guidance regarding performance advertising into a single, fairly prescriptive rule.
To start, while the Marketing Rule contains seven general prohibitions applicable to all investment adviser advertising activities (including testimonials, endorsements, and third-party ratings, covered in a previous Nerd’s Eye View post), there are seven additional prohibitions applicable specifically to performance advertising. The first rule prohibits advisers from presenting gross performance without also presenting net performance with at least equal prominence, so that investors can assess returns that are actually received, net of fees and expenses paid in connection with the adviser’s services, and helping prospective clients better compare returns across different advisers.
The Marketing Rule also requires performance results to be presented consistently over 1-, 5-, and 10-year time periods (or the time period the portfolio has existed, if shorter than a particular prescribed period) preventing advisers from cherry-picking time periods that would make their returns appear more favorable. Furthermore, investment advisers may generally reference the performance results of related portfolios only if all related portfolios are included in the advertisement. Further, an investment adviser is prohibited from advertising performance results of a subset of investments extracted from a portfolio unless the advertisement provides, or offers to provide promptly, the performance results of the total portfolio from which the performance was extracted.
The SEC has heavily scrutinized the use of hypothetical performance in advertising for many years, and its restrictive stance is codified in the updated Marketing Rule. What actually constitutes hypothetical performance is quite broad and essentially includes any performance result that was not actually achieved by a portfolio of the investment adviser, and its distribution is limited to investors who are considered capable of independently analyzing the information and understanding the associated risks and limitations. Two final prohibitions under the Marketing Rule include restrictions on the use of predecessor performance (e.g., performance by an investment adviser before it was spun out from another adviser or by its personnel while they were employed elsewhere), as well as advertising that explicitly states or implies that that the calculation or presentation of performance results has been approved or reviewed by the SEC.
Ultimately, the key point is that the SEC’s recently overhauled Marketing Rule provides a consolidated set of guidelines for advisers to understand how RIAs are permitted to use advertising. Though, given the potential for future SEC guidance clarifying the new rule, or even possible Risk Alerts summarizing common deficiencies and best practices it observes during the course of its upcoming examinations, advisers looking to use performance advertising will want to pay close attention to how it is enforced in practice!
Welcome back to the 310th episode of the Financial Advisor Success Podcast!
My guest on today's podcast is Natalie Taylor. Natalie is the owner of Natalie Taylor Consulting Services, an independent virtual RIA, and is also the Head of Financial Advice for Monarch Money, a personal financial management tool that helps consumers track their spending and net worth over time.
What's unique about Natalie, though, is how, during her years of working for a FinTech company, she realized that providing valuable financial advice that is more affordable for the masses ultimately requires collecting only the data, and delivering only the advice, that will provide the greatest amount of impact and value to the client… and filtering out the rest that just isn’t cost-effective advice for the end consumer.
In this episode, we talk in-depth about how, while working for LearnVest, Natalie realized that their financial advisors were much more limited by the constraints of data, time, and fees, than the traditional advisor, which inspired her to develop a framework that focuses on providing only the most impactful financial advice to help clients move forward right now, how while also working at LearnVest, Natalie developed a ‘brand voice guide’ to help all of their advisors communicate advice to clients more consistently, that revolved around 5 principles for advisors to implement during the advice delivery process (including “be the Coach”, “be the Expert”, “be the Cheerleader”, “wide lens/narrow lens”, and “listen and direct”), and how the acquisition of LearnVest by a large financial services company, and the repurposing of its technology tools, ultimately led to Natalie leaving and having to dismantle the advice offering she originally helped build and develop.
We also talk about how, in the early stages of Natalie’s career, she felt that as a young advisor she was not prepared to give advice at the level of an expert and instead switched firms to work with a mentor who recognized her talents and gave her more opportunities to work with higher caliber clients (and really build her confidence with them), how, after leaving LearnVest, Natalie focused on speaking engagements and consulting but reached a crossroads as she recognized she missed the type of direct impact she had for clients in her previous roles that doesn’t come from consulting alone, and how Natalie realized that she did not have to choose between her desire to provide a breadth of impact through a FinTech or a depth of impact with personal financial planning and instead chose to do both, by splitting her time between the launch of her own independent RIA while simultaneously joining a personal financial management tool company, Monarch Money, as the head of financial advice where she could help them systematize advice for the masses.
And be certain to listen to the end, where Natalie shares how working in FinTech and at an RIA helped her understand how important it is to balance between advice that is exact and solutions that may not be as ideal but helps the client actually move forward and take the next positive step, why Natalie believes it is important for newer, younger advisors to not get discouraged by the uncertainty of career paths and instead concentrate on getting clear on what values are important to them and using those values as a filter to find the next steps on their paths, and why Natalie believes the key to her success stems from developing her own personal list of 6 core values that she and her husband use to filter their major family and career decisions… and review each year to ensure the ongoing decisions they are making are still in alignment with what is really most important to them, and can keep propelling them forward in their careers and their lives.
So, whether you’re interested in learning about how Natalie dealt with having to dismantle the FinTech she helped develop, why Natalie ultimately decided to work simultaneously for a FinTech company and her own RIA, or why Natalie focuses her work on the meaningful impact she can provide in her clients’ lives, then we hope you enjoy this episode of the Financial Advisor Success podcast, with Natalie Taylor.
Welcome to the December 2022 issue of the Latest News in Financial #AdvisorTech – where we look at the big news, announcements, and underlying trends and developments that are emerging in the world of technology solutions for financial advisors!
This month's edition kicks off with the news that Savvy Wealth has raised an $11M Series A round to compete in the new category of ‘tech-enabled RIA’ – where the firm will use the bulk of its capital to develop its own in-house fully-integrated advisor tech stack, in the hopes that a better technology experience will both attract advisors to work for the firm, attract consumers to want to be clients of the firm, and enable their advisors to service more clients (and be more productive) with the firm.
Notably, though, the reality is that while few would argue that today’s ‘best-of-breed’ approach of cobbling together independent advisor technology solutions is perfect, advisory firms on average have continued to run remarkably healthy 25% - 30% profit margins, suggesting that while the technology may not be perfect, it’s not that broken, either. With a select number of ‘all-in-one’ solutions that form a consistent hub (around which the rest of the advisor tech stack is at least reasonably integrated), and a subset of tasks that can be solved with just a little extra administrative support, it’s not clear whether firms like Savvy can build technology that really materially alters the productivity and profit margins of a tech-enabled RIA. Not to mention that for most firms, the biggest inhibitor to expanding reach and growing faster is not its back-office technology efficiencies, but the cost of attracting new clients in the first place… which raises the question of whether Savvy is bringing (or raising capital to fund) an operational solution to what is still first and foremost a marketing problem?
From there, the latest highlights also feature a number of other interesting advisor technology announcements, including:
Read the analysis about these announcements in this month's column, and a discussion of more trends in advisor technology, including:
In the meantime, we’re excited to announce several new updates to our new Kitces AdvisorTech Directory, including Advisor Satisfaction scores from our Kitces AdvisorTech Research, and the inclusion of WealthTech Integration scores from the Ezra Group!
And be certain to read to the end, where we have provided an update to our popular “Financial AdvisorTech Solutions Map” as well!
*And for #AdvisorTech companies who want to submit their tech announcements for consideration in future issues, please submit to [email protected]!
See How Successful Advisors Are Communicating And Demonstrating The Ongoing Value Of Financial Planning
December 8, 2022 • 12:00 – 4:00 p.m. EDT
Instead of telling you what you ‘should’ be doing as an advisor, our Kitces Summit guests are all practicing financial advisors who will actually show you what actions they’ve taken to demonstrate their upfront and ongoing financial planning value to clients, so you can see what’s really possible for yourself.
The transition from “pure” investment management services to providing more holistic financial planning has been underway for more than a decade, as advisory firms either try to expand their value to defend against fee compression, or increasingly offer advice as a standalone service to generate standalone advice fees. Yet the challenge is that historically, financial planning was always paid via subsequent product implementation, or as a part of an AUM fee… such that advisors have never really had to ‘prove’ their financial planning value the way they do now with a more fee-for-service approach.
At the Kitces Financial Planning Value Summit, you’ll have a chance to see what ongoing financial planning value looks like when it’s done successfully, with a unique behind the scenes look at real financial advisors’ tactics to demonstrate their value upfront to prospects and ongoing with clients.
No vendors. No sponsors. Just a series of 30-minute real conversations between our co-hosts – Michael Kitces and Taylor Schulte – and our expert guests, financial advisors who will screenshare their actual financial planning deliverables and show how they communicate their value to prospects and clients.
See the real deliverables our guests use with their clients
Kitces Summit Attendee Workbook
____
Tiffany Charles – Questions Used in Assessment
Tiffany Charles – PointerPro-Client Assessment
Tiffany Charles – Destiny Capital-Client Assessment
____
Kyle Moore – Service Calendars
Kyle Moore – Sample Financial Plan
Kyle Moore – Sample Estate Flowchart
Kyle Moore – Sample Annual Tax Letter
Kyle Moore – Annual Planning Process
____
Jake Northrup – Year-End One-Page Review
Jake Northrup – Onboarding Process
Jake Northrup – MeisterTask Template
Jake Northrup – MeisterTask Client Template
____
Michael Whitman – What Issues Should I Consider
Michael Whitman – Visual Insights Newsletter
Michael Whitman – Timely Email What Happens Next
Michael Whitman – Sample Pulse360 Agenda
Michael Whitman – October Client Review Email
Michael Whitman – fpPathfinder Checklist
____
Jason Pereira – Prospect Process
Jason Pereira – Welcome Presentation – Template
Jason Pereira – John Smith Graphic Summary
Jason Pereira – CFPA Submission
Jason Pereira – John Smith Scenarios (Text)
____
Carolyn McClanahan – Investment Philosophy
Michael and Taylor will keep each session focused on what matters most: what advisors are doing that works.
Michael is the Head of Planning Strategy at Buckingham Wealth Partners and is a passionate advocate for evolving, expanding, and institutionalizing excellence in financial planning. In addition, he is a co-founder of the XY Planning Network, the former Practitioner Editor of the Journal of Financial Planning, and the publisher of the e-newsletter The Kitces Report and the popular financial planning industry blog Nerd’s Eye View through his website www.Kitces.com, dedicated to advancing knowledge in financial planning.
Taylor Schulte, CFP® is the founder of Define Financial, a fee-only retirement planning firm in San Diego, CA. In addition, he is the co-founder of The AGC community and hosts a popular marketing podcast for financial advisors called Experiments in Advisor Marketing. Schulte has been recognized as a Top 40 Advisor Under 40 by InvestmentNews and as a Top 10 independent financial advisor by Investopedia.
Each guest will screenshare their actual education-based marketing strategies and show how they attract prospects and establish trust.
Tiffany Charles, Chief Growth Officer and Partner of Destiny Capital and Entrepreneur Aligned, is primarily responsible for firm growth and leading their talented team in the areas of business development, client experience, professional relationships, specialty markets, and marketing. With over 11 years of experience in the financial services industry and another 5 in commercial real estate, Tiffany has experienced and planned for many forms of success, entrepreneurship, and wealth creation. She has a battle-tested talent in establishing and cultivating meaningful relationships and is extremely passionate about bridging the gap that exists between entrepreneurs' financial success and the remarkable life they desire.
Kyle Moore founded Quarry Hill Advisors in 2017, now managing over $200M of investment assets for 160 households while delivering a top-notch financial planning process.
Jake is the founder of Experience Your Wealth, a virtual fee-only financial planning firm helping travel-loving young families find the right balance between paying down debt, investing for the future, but also experiencing life now. He is a Certified Financial Planner, Chartered Financial Analyst and Certified Student Loan Professional. Jake has been named a 2022 Investopedia Top 100 Financial Advisor, 2021 Young Advisor To Watch by Financial Advisor Magazine, Investment News 2020 40 Under 40 class and a 2020 top financial planner for millennials by Business Insider.
Michael has over a decade of financial services experience working with companies such as Prudential and Lincoln Financial. He enjoys working with both the young professional needing to understand their options, and the baby boomer needing to maximize income. Over the years, he’s observed a tremendous gap in knowledge between today’s retiring generation and the ones just now starting to save. People may not be able to rely on the strategies used by previous generations of Financial Planners.
Michael has developed deep expertise in insurance solutions for clients with a variety of needs and objectives. He prides himself on sharing his knowledge with his clients - and doing so in a transparent, objective manner. Michael graduated from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill where he studied Dramatic Art and is a CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER™ professional.
Jason Pereira is a partner at Woodgate Financial in Toronto, Canada. He is a well-known and accomplished financial planner, industry advocate, fintech and practice management expert. He holds two degrees and nine industry designations and has either been a finalist or a winner of over 40 industry awards.
His commentary and writing have appeared in every major media outlet in the country, and he currently serves as a columnist and advisory board member of the Globe & Mail's Globe Advisor and is the host of two podcasts: Fintech Impact and The Financial Planning for Canadian Business Owners Podcast.
Jason also holds the position of the founding President of the Financial Planning Association of Canada, a director of the Institute of Advanced Financial Planners, and a director of the Individual Finance and Insurance Decision Centre.
Carolyn McClanahan, M.D., CFP® is the founder of Life Planning Partners, Inc. Dr. McClanahan began her career as a physician in 1990 after completing her undergraduate degree at Mississippi University for Women and medical school at University of Mississippi. She completed her residency in Family Medicine at the Medical College of Virginia. After a couple of years in private practice and emergency medicine practice in Richmond, Virginia, she moved to teach at the University of Florida, Jacksonville. She also worked in various emergency departments in the Jacksonville area. Finding that most financial planners were mainly interested in managing her portfolio and not in providing the advice she needed, she enrolled in the CFP® curriculum at the University of North Florida.
Realizing the similarities between medicine and financial planning, and feeling more empowered by being able to help people plan for their future, Dr. McClanahan decided to make a career change into financial planning. In addition to working in her financial life planning practice, Dr. McClanahan provides education to financial planners and health care professionals on the interplay between health and financial issues, particularly regarding insurability, health care costs, and health care reform. She writes for Barron’s, Forbes, and CNBC covering issues intersecting money and medicine. Investopedia ranked her as a top 10 advisor making significant contributions to critical conversations about financial life-stage planning. Dr. McClanahan is a member of the National Association of Personal Financial Advisors (NAPFA,) the Financial Planning Association, and the American Academy of Family Physicians. She serves on the CNBC Financial Advisor Council and is quoted regularly in numerous publications such as The Wall Street Journal, New York Times, and the Washington Post. She has also appeared on CNBC, Hardball, AC360, and NPR.
Kitces.com Premier Membership includes Kitces-Courses discounts, free monthly webinars, over 100 Hours of CE on-demand, CFP ethics, and more!
Discounts are available for group enrollments. Additional discounts apply with a Kitces Premier Group Membership .
As financial planning has evolved over the years, better tools have become available to help advisors maximize their impact with more clients by increasing their efficiency. Financial planning technology, in particular, has allowed advisors to automate time-intensive back-office tasks and delegate routine analyses to support staff, freeing up their time to engage more personally with clients. However, as advisor technology continues to evolve, many tools have focused on helping advisors scale their financial advice to accommodate growing businesses. And while these tools are marketed as helping advisors become more efficient, advisors often wonder if technology helps them offer better financial planning or if it simply serves to systematize outreach to more clients with depersonalized and less insightful advice.
In our 100th episode of Kitces & Carl, Michael Kitces and client communication expert Carl Richards discuss the evolution of advisor technology, how advisor technology has shifted the focus for many firms toward offering advice at scale by leveraging speed and efficiency, and whether advisor technology is truly helping make advisors better… or just faster.
As a starting point, it’s important to recognize that while conversations in the financial services industry over the last decade have entertained the idea that technology (e.g., robo-advisors) might someday replace human advisors, there are still many elements of financial planning that benefit from engagement with a human advisor. As while advisors certainly can leverage technology to create faster and more efficient back-office processes that help scale a growing practice, the key point is that new technology tools can also help advisors engage in better conversations through innovative presentation tools (e.g., interactive scenario modeling, data management, and visualization), helping them create more meaningful client relationships. And by aiming to scale the delivery of advice to make the process faster will not necessarily be better for clients, because the reality is that clients are humans with complicated histories and relationships with money; even though it may be more efficient to provide them with easy-to-use do-it-yourself financial technology to help them budget and track their own progress, many will still need extra time with their advisor to help them work through more complex issues preventing them from reaching their financial goals. And maintaining positive, supportive relationships with clients who are struggling to overcome emotional and behavioral challenges around money takes time.
Ultimately, advisor technology can help advisory firms scale their businesses by improving back-office efficiencies, but it does not necessarily serve to help financial advisors scale the work of actually giving financial advice… at least not yet. While the challenge of delivering advice at scale is perhaps better addressed through serving more clients by adjusting the firm’s business models instead of their chosen technology tools, there are technology tools available that can help advisors provide better advice by facilitating deeper discussions of the client’s unique situation, which can result in longer-lasting and more meaningful client relationships!
Taxes are a central component of financial planning. Almost every financial planning issue – whether it is retirement, investments, cash flow, insurance, or estate planning – has tax considerations, and advisors provide a great deal of value in helping clients minimize their overall tax burden. And yet, despite the prominent role of taxes in financial planning, advisors are often prohibited by their compliance departments from making recommendations for a specific course of action on a certain tax strategy. Which means that advisors are often left to figure out on their own how to guide their clients on tax-related matters without crossing the line into ‘Tax Advice’, which can potentially create certain liability issues for the advisor and their firm.
This is not because of any blanket regulation against financial advisors making tax recommendations. Although the IRS states that only designated tax professionals like attorneys, CPAs, and EAs can give advice on certain strategies (e.g., those that are designed to avoid taxation, such as tax shelters, that have a high potential for abusing tax laws), many of the tax strategies that financial advisors recommend are not meant to shelter income to avoid taxation altogether, but are instead designed to ensure that income is simply taxed more efficiently, such as by optimizing the timing or nature of income when it is taxed (e.g., Roth conversion strategies involve recognizing taxable income via the conversion to ensure funds are taxed at the lowest possible rate). From the IRS’s perspective, there is no requirement to be a designated tax professional in order to give advice on such strategies that optimize taxation.
For many advisors, engaging in tax advice is often prohibited because of the potential legal and financial liabilities that are opened up for advisors and their firms. Unlike investment advice, advisory firms are usually not required to create policies and procedures around properly given tax advice (unless they specifically employ designated tax practitioners), so there is often no clear-cut way to ensure tax advice is given correctly. And the consequences for incorrect tax advice can include legal and financial penalties if a client were to be harmed by the wrong advice – which is often not covered by the firm’s E&O insurance –creating an expensive liability when tax advice goes wrong.
For advisors who are prohibited from giving tax advice, tax planning can be an alternative approach for discussing tax matters with clients. Tax planning can range from giving general, nonspecific information on tax laws and regulations to creating detailed projections for clients and comparing the outcomes of potential tax strategies – so long as the planning does not also include a recommendation of a specific course of action that would constitute tax advice. Generally, the more detailed the analysis, the likelier it could be construed by the client as a recommendation – which is what ultimately matters, since a presentation that the client understands to be tax advice is as good as actually giving tax advice. In these circumstances, safeguards such as upfront disclosures and collaboration with the client’s tax professional may be necessary to ensure that the tax professional – and not the advisor – is the one making the actual recommendation.
The key point is that understanding what constitutes tax advice versus tax planning that doesn’t go so far as to make a recommendation can help advisors more confidently engage with their clients on tax matters without violating the unique rules set in place by their compliance departments. Having a framework for the types of advice to give and for the language to use when communicating strategies to clients can reduce the confusion of being obliged to provide guidance on taxes while being prohibited from giving actual tax advice. Because ultimately, the question around tax planning (if not outright advice) isn’t whether it should be offered, but how it can be delivered to provide the most value to clients while protecting the client, advisor, and firm!
General Inquiries: [email protected]
Members Assistance: [email protected]
All Other Questions,
Or Reach Michael Directly:
This browser is no longer supported by Microsoft and may have performance, security, or missing functionality issues. For the best experience using Kitces.com we recommend using one of the following browsers.